-
Website
http://mashable.com/ -
Original page
http://mashable.com/2009/08/13/project-retweet/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
Robert Basil
142 comments · 8 points
-
Jennifer Van Grove
149 comments · 23 points
-
r0cketman22
317 comments · 52 points
-
rajagiri4
160 comments · 2 points
-
barringtonarch
150 comments · 4 points
-
-
Popular Threads
-
Enter the Zappos Sharing Happiness $3,000 Shopping Spree Giveaway Contest
11 hours ago · 110 comments
-
Head to Head: Chrome for Mac vs. Chrome for Windows
7 hours ago · 22 comments
-
REVEALED: Details on YouTube’s VEVO Music Video Site
3 hours ago · 12 comments
-
Redbox: The Enemy of the Entertainment Industry? [STUDY]
2 hours ago · 9 comments
-
Holiday Mojo: What Kind of Seasonal Twitter User Are You?
4 hours ago · 14 comments
-
Enter the Zappos Sharing Happiness $3,000 Shopping Spree Giveaway Contest
Currently, all retweets are text copies of the original tweet, with the username thrown in as a courtesy. There is no explicit link between the original tweet and the retweet. Sure, a couple analytics programs can parse all of the text on twitter and find implicit links between similar tweets, but allowing RTs to be made with an API call will leave an permanent trail from the original poster to the entire pyramid of RTs that happen, no matter how many users pass the tweet along.
It's the same idea behind "in reply to" on replies. Remember when a reply used to link to the wrong tweet? Then one day they suddenly were able to link to the correct tweet. This is the same kind of thing.
The fact that you can do one-click RTs in third party apps means nothing. This is not a user interface enhancement, it is primarily an "under the hood" improvement that will allow a whole world of new possibilities in terms of tracking your content as it spreads across Twitter.
Michelle Chun-Hoon
CKR Interactive Intern
CKRInteractive.com
I suspect a partial fail in this improvement coming on.
What's more, they fundamentally misconstrue how many people use retweeting -- which is not just to pass along the original tweet but often, if there's room, to comment on it as well. This "solution" renders that impossible.
Much like the asinine "users are too confused by the option to see all replies" debacle, Twitter's only showing that it once again fails to understand how people are actually using their service.
What's more, they fundamentally misconstrue how many people use retweeting -- which is not just to pass along the original tweet but often, if there's room, to comment on it as well. This "solution" renders that impossible.
Much like the asinine "users are too confused by the option to see all replies" debacle, Twitter's only showing that it once again fails to understand how people are actually using their service.
http://twitter.com/silenciobarnes
http://silenciobarnes.com
If Twitter expects to survive and compete against a flurry of Facebook / Google udpates and progression to making conversation and sharing info as efficient as possible, then Twitter needs to add "comment" functionality right in the Twitter stream.
So what's my point?
Twitter needs to add commenting to the stream - PERIOD!
If they don't - they will eventually become nothing more than a source of spam broadcasts!
MARK MY WORDS.... mark my words!
Like currently, say I found a tweet by like this: "@bob: I like pie", I would tweet "Me too. RT @bob: I like pie."
Is that...possible to do with this?
"One click retweet" means I cannot edit the original at all -- no adding my commentary, no changing a passed URL to a bit.ly link that shows how many times *my* followers click it, no changes at all.
@Replies are *still* broken, so threaded conversation doesn't work as it *should* with post-reply-reply-reply -- they have to be post-post-post-post to be seen by people who don't follow us both.
What will Twitter break next? Leaving power users straining at the bit, waiting for the NEW site/tool/what-have-you that delivers *something* of what the old Usenet did... even if that's still a pale, pale shadow of the original... which at least includes the CONVERSATION which is the core of ALL social network sites/tools/what-have-you.
It's sad. Twitter *was* horrible and stupid, and yet delivered value. It's becoming horrible and stupid and *lacking* value. Sad, indeed.
ReThink the ReTweet. Please.
You can then take your free credits and get your own messages retweeted. There is also an option for people that do not want to wait to earn retweets to just pay for the user community to review their tweets and if they want to send or retweet the message to their followers they can.
Usually only the best tweets get retweeted. This is a powerful promotion tool for those on Twitter.